At late-2026 prices, buying a median $417,500 home with 10% down at a 7.24% mortgage rate costs about $3,700 a month including taxes, insurance, maintenance and mortgage insurance — roughly $1,200 more than renting a comparable $2,500 home. Counting only money you don't get back, buying overtakes renting after about nine years in our example. Stay shorter, and renting usually wins; stay longer, or buy where rents are high relative to prices, and owning comes out ahead.
The numbers right now
| Late 2026 | |
|---|---|
| Median existing-home price (September) | $417,500 |
| Average 30-year fixed mortgage rate (October 29) | 7.24% |
| Same rate a year earlier | 6.19% |
| National median rent, all apartments (September) | $1,388 |
| Average home insurance premium (mid-2026) | $3,012 a year |
Mortgage rates have climbed about a full percentage point in a year, while home prices are still edging up — 1.3% over the past year, the 39th straight monthly gain on a year-over-year basis. That combination is why the question matters again.
What owning really costs each month
Example: a $417,500 home, 10% down ($41,750), a $375,750 loan at 7.24% for 30 years.
| Monthly cost of owning | Amount |
|---|---|
| Principal and interest | $2,561 |
| Property tax (1.1% a year) | $383 |
| Home insurance | $251 |
| Maintenance (1% of value a year) | $348 |
| Private mortgage insurance (0.5% of the loan a year) | $157 |
| Total | about $3,700 |
Compare that with rent of $2,500 for a similar house. The gap is about $1,200 a month. Part of the mortgage payment is principal — money you keep as home equity — but in the first years most of it is interest. See amortization.
The five-year test
The fair comparison is not rent versus mortgage payment. It is money you never get back on each side.
| Over 5 years | Buy | Rent |
|---|---|---|
| Rent paid (rising 3% a year) | — | $159,300 |
| Mortgage interest | $132,500 | — |
| Taxes, insurance, maintenance, PMI | $68,300 | — |
| Closing costs to buy (3%) | $12,500 | — |
| Selling costs (6% of the future price) | $29,000 | — |
| Price growth (3% a year) | −$66,500 | — |
| Lost interest on the down payment and closing costs (4%) | $11,800 | — |
| Money you don't get back | about $187,600 | about $159,300 |
After five years, renting is about $28,000 cheaper in this example. Buying catches up only in year nine.
What moves the break-even point
| If this changes… | Buying beats renting after |
|---|---|
| Our base case | 9 years |
| Home prices grow 5% a year, not 3% | 4 years |
| Home prices grow 1% a year | 17 years |
| Mortgage rate is 6.25%, not 7.24% | 6 years |
| A similar home rents for $3,000 | 5 years |
| A similar home rents for $2,000 | 14 years |
The two levers you control are how long you stay and what you pay relative to local rent. A quick check: divide the price by a year of rent for a comparable home. Here $417,500 ÷ $30,000 ≈ 14. The higher that ratio, the stronger the case for renting.
Why it matters to you
A home is the biggest purchase most people make, and the monthly payment hides most of its real cost. Buying too early — before you know you'll stay — can cost tens of thousands of dollars in transaction costs alone. Renting while investing the difference can build wealth too, but only if the difference is actually invested.
What you can do
- Write down how long you realistically expect to stay. Under five years, renting usually wins.
- Price the full monthly cost of owning, not only the mortgage payment — use the table above with your local tax rate and insurance quote.
- Compare with the rent of a truly similar home in the same area.
- If you rent, automate the monthly difference into savings or investments.
- Read: the real cost of ownership and when it makes sense to refinance.
FAQ
Isn't rent just throwing money away?
No more than mortgage interest, property tax and insurance are. Both sides have costs you don't get back; the comparison above counts them.
Should I wait for mortgage rates to fall?
Nobody knows when they will. If you buy now and rates fall, you may be able to refinance — but that has costs too, and prices may rise in the meantime.
Does the mortgage interest deduction change the math?
For most households, no. Since the standard deduction roughly doubled in 2018, most homeowners don't itemize, so the deduction often saves little or nothing.
What about building equity?
It is real, but slow at first. After five years in our example the loan balance falls by only about $21,000.
How does a rent vs buy calculator work?
It compares two paths over the same years. Owning: down payment, mortgage interest, property tax, insurance, maintenance and selling costs, minus the home's growth in value. Renting: rent and renter's insurance, plus what the down payment would have earned if invested. The year the two lines cross is your break-even. See total cost of ownership and home equity.
Sources
This article is for information only and is not investment, tax or legal advice. Figures are given with their source and date.
